On Now
Coming Up
  • Wed., Jul. 23, 2014 5:00 PM CDT Ask Vic Day

    “Ask Vic Day” will include dinner and a movie, an “Ask Vic Live,” and a few other surprises along the way. The event will be held on July 23, 2014, at Lambeau Field. Registration will begin at 4 pm with a 5 pm kickoff. Door prizes will be awarded during the reception.

    Cost per person is $35 (tax included).

  • Wed., Jul. 23, 2014 8:00 PM - 9:30 PM CDT Aaron Adams appearance Aaron Adams will make an appearance at the Ohio Valley Regional Event in Pedersen Park in Marinette, WI on Wednesday, July 23, from 8-9:30 p.m.
  • Thu., Jul. 24, 2014 11:00 AM CDT Shareholders Meeting

    The Green Bay Packers 2014 Annual Meeting of Shareholders will be held Thursday, July 24, at 11 a.m., at Lambeau Field. The meeting will take place rain or shine.

  • Fri., Jul. 25, 2014 6:00 PM CDT Packers 1K Kids Run

    Back to Football also includes the 1K Kids Run, presented by WPS Health Insurance. Kids 10 years old and younger will have the opportunity to run a Lambeau Lap on Friday, July 25, at 6 p.m. Registration for the Kids Run is $10 and all participants will receive a Packers 1K Run t-shirt, a logoed bag and a participant medal.

    http://www.packers.com/5k

  • Fri., Jul. 25, 2014 7:00 PM CDT Movie Night at Lambeau Field

    Movie Night at Lambeau Field will return this year on Friday, July 25, following the 1K Kids Run. The event is free and open to the public, and concessions will be available throughout the movie. More details will be announced at a later date.

    Time listed above is subject to change.

  • Sat., Jul. 26, 2014 6:30 PM CDT Packers 5K Run/Walk

    The fifth annual ‘5K Run/Walk at Lambeau Field,’ is set for Saturday, July 26, at 6:30 p.m.

    The computer-timed run is highlighted by a neighborhood route that ultimately takes participants into Lambeau Field and around the famed gridiron. The event has a special finish line – the Packers’ ‘G’ painted on turf located in the parking lot.

    All participants will receive a Packers 5K Run T-shirt, a logoed bag, and a bib number and timing chip. To celebrate the race’s fifth anniversary, all participants will receive a commemorative medal. In addition, photos will be taken on the course and will be available at no cost on the Packers 5K Run website.

    Packers-themed awards will be presented to the top three finishers in each age group. An awards ceremony will take place following the conclusion of the race.

    Registration, which is $25 for adults and $15 for children (12 and younger), will be available online beginning Friday, May 23, at www.packers.com/5k. Mail-in registration is also an option, with forms available online and in person at Lambeau Field. Runners can also register at the Bellin Run Expo on Friday, June 13, at Astor Park in Green Bay. Early registration is encouraged. After July 13, registration fees will increase to $30 and $20, respectively.

News

Print
RSS

Point, counterpoint: Would a 30-day disabled list be a good idea?

Posted Oct 30, 2012

Vic KetchmanPackers.com Editor Vic Ketchman says no.

It’s a great idea, if you like cheating, because that’s what a 30-day disabled list would produce.

Hey, we’ve been down this road before. Back in the ’70s, the NFL instituted a rule that allowed a four-week return from injured reserve. Teams could bring players back to the active roster from IR four times in a season. It was a great rule that allowed teams to patch a hole in their roster without losing the injured player for the season.

The spirit of the rule was all good, but the application of the rule was violated by teams – frankly, it was every team – that used the rule as a means for manipulating and stashing talent. For example, a backup wide receiver with a minor injury that shouldn’t have necessitated a move to IR was sent there because the team temporarily got caught short on the offensive line but didn’t want to IR the injured starter because he’d only be out a game or two. So, they’d sign a lineman for a game or two, then cut him and sign somebody to another position that was a little depleted, and so forth and so on. If they’d need the wide receiver later in the season, they’d use one of their four moves on him.

In effect, the four-week IR rule was a 30-day disabled list, and NFL owners decided the roster, which hovered between 43-47 in those days, was large enough; it didn’t need to add four more roster spots, which is what the four-week rule effectively did.

Today, we have 53 players on the active roster and eight practice-squad players in the locker room that are practicing with the team and learning the team’s playbook. How many players are enough?

The length of training camp has been cut in half, two-a-days are gone and full-pads practices are costume parties compared to the mosh pits of the ’70s. Hasn’t the league done enough to help protect teams and players from injury?

For those of you who would say the league hasn’t done enough, that it needs to provide a disabled list, I would remind you that there is a cost for expanding the roster, and that cost is likely to be passed onto the fan.

Look, if a guy is too good to lose but and not injured badly enough to be lost for the season, then just carry him on your 53, as the Packers are doing with Charles Woodson. Only 46 of those 53 players can play on Sunday, so seven of the 53 are held in reserve, which means those seven are effectively a disabled list, right?

OK, let’s hear the whining and crying side of it now.

Mike SpoffordPackers.com Staff Writer Mike Spofford says yes.

I’m not going to whine and cry, but I do think it would be a good idea.

Mike McCarthy had to cut practices short all last week because of the shortage of players available, and I don’t think it’s a coincidence that the roll the Packers had begun on offense came to a screeching halt against one of the league’s lower-ranked defenses.

This isn’t the ’70s anymore. Teams are much more interested in protecting their multi-million-dollar investments in players long term, and they should have the option of removing an injured player from the roster for a month without having to make an anguishing IR decision or short-change the team in the meantime.

As for the manipulation and stashing of talent that occurred in the past, that was long before the advent of free agency, long before players had a much stronger say in where they play. If a guy isn’t hurt and the team is using a disabled list to stash him, he can use the union to file a grievance. If he’s truly good enough to keep in house, his current team won’t risk alienating him like that and gaining a reputation for jerking players around. That would matter in the free-agency era. Nobody gave a whit in the ’70s because clubs had all the control.

It’s a long season, and teams need to be given reasonable tools to navigate the long grind from a health standpoint. They only played 14 games back in the ’70s, until 1978 anyway, and had one less round of playoffs.

Look, I’m not suggesting the players the Packers could sign to replace the likes of Charles Woodson and Greg Jennings if a 30-day DL were available would be able to make a huge impact and change the season.

But a team would at least be able to carry something closer to a full roster and not have to cut practices short because there aren’t enough players available to conduct a full workout. It goes to the quality of the product on Sundays, and the only ones cheated in the end are the fans.

Cast your vote in the poll on the right, please.

 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Vote Here!
What was the Packers' play of the year in 2013?